Bug report
Bug description
shutil.ReadError and shutil.RegistryError are not included in shutil.__all__, making them inaccessible via wildcard import. Both exceptions are actively raised by public API functions:
ReadError is raised by unpack_archive()
RegistryError is raised by register_unpack_format()
The other shutil exceptions (Error, SameFileError, SpecialFileError) are all in __all__.
>>> from shutil import *
>>> try:
... unpack_archive("nonexistent.zip")
... except ReadError:
... pass
...
NameError: name 'ReadError' is not defined. Did you mean: 'KeyError'?
Impact
from shutil import * does not export ReadError or RegistryError, so users cannot catch exceptions raised by unpack_archive() or register_unpack_format() without explicitly importing them by name.
- Neither exception is documented in
Doc/library/shutil.rst, while the other three shutil exceptions (Error, SameFileError, SpecialFileError) all have dedicated .. exception:: entries.
- Tools that rely on
__all__ for API discovery (linters, IDE autocompletion, documentation generators) will not surface these exceptions.
This was introduced in commit 6ac9172 (bpo-8295, 2010) which added the archive functions and exceptions but did not add ReadError or RegistryError to __all__. A later fix for incomplete __all__ (#66855, 2014) added SameFileError but missed these two.
Verified on Python 3.14.3 in a clean venv.
Proposed fix
Add "ReadError" and "RegistryError" to __all__ in Lib/shutil.py, and add .. exception:: entries in Doc/library/shutil.rst to document them alongside the other exceptions.
CPython versions tested on:
3.14
Operating system:
All
Linked PRs
Bug report
Bug description
shutil.ReadErrorandshutil.RegistryErrorare not included inshutil.__all__, making them inaccessible via wildcard import. Both exceptions are actively raised by public API functions:ReadErroris raised byunpack_archive()RegistryErroris raised byregister_unpack_format()The other shutil exceptions (
Error,SameFileError,SpecialFileError) are all in__all__.Impact
from shutil import *does not exportReadErrororRegistryError, so users cannot catch exceptions raised byunpack_archive()orregister_unpack_format()without explicitly importing them by name.Doc/library/shutil.rst, while the other three shutil exceptions (Error,SameFileError,SpecialFileError) all have dedicated.. exception::entries.__all__for API discovery (linters, IDE autocompletion, documentation generators) will not surface these exceptions.This was introduced in commit 6ac9172 (bpo-8295, 2010) which added the archive functions and exceptions but did not add
ReadErrororRegistryErrorto__all__. A later fix for incomplete__all__(#66855, 2014) addedSameFileErrorbut missed these two.Verified on Python 3.14.3 in a clean venv.
Proposed fix
Add
"ReadError"and"RegistryError"to__all__inLib/shutil.py, and add.. exception::entries inDoc/library/shutil.rstto document them alongside the other exceptions.CPython versions tested on:
3.14
Operating system:
All
Linked PRs
shutil.ReadErrorandshutil.RegistryError#148004