Skip to content
Merged
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
188 changes: 188 additions & 0 deletions unit-testing/SKILL.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,188 @@
# Unit Testing (Osherove 3rd Edition)
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

P1 Badge Add required YAML frontmatter at file start

This skill omits the --- YAML frontmatter block (name, description, etc.) that the rest of this repo’s skills use and that power-builder/SKILL.md documents as required for SKILL metadata; starting directly with a markdown heading makes this file inconsistent with the expected skill format and can cause loaders that parse frontmatter for discovery/display to skip or misclassify the new skill.

Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.


Write and review unit tests following Roy Osherove's "The Art of Unit Testing" (3rd Edition) principles, including entry points, exit points, and trust boundaries.

## When to Use

Activate this skill when:
- Writing new unit tests
- Reviewing existing test quality
- Refactoring tests for readability/maintainability
- Deciding what to test and how to structure tests
- Identifying missing test coverage via exit points

## Core Concepts

### Entry Points
The public API surface through which the unit under test is invoked:
- Public methods/functions
- Constructors
- Event subscriptions
- CLI arguments
- IPC messages / HTTP endpoints

### Exit Points (what to verify)
Every unit has 1+ exit points. Each test should verify exactly **one exit point**:

1. **Return value** — function returns a result
2. **State change** — observable state mutation (property, file, DB)
3. **Dependency call** — calls to a dependency (3rd party, network, I/O)

### Trust Boundaries
- **Don't mock what you own** — test real code paths unless I/O is involved
- **Mock at the boundary** — mock only external dependencies (network, filesystem, time)
- **Don't test internals** — test behavior through entry points, not implementation

## Naming Convention

```
[UnitOfWork]_[Scenario]_[ExpectedBehavior]
```

Examples:
```typescript
describe("IpcServer", () => {
it("start_whenSocketAlreadyInUse_throwsAlreadyRunningError")
it("start_withStaleSocket_removesAndListens")
it("handler_withInvalidJson_returnsErrorResponse")
it("handler_whenPayloadExceeds64KB_destroysConnection")
});
```

Or the shorter readable form (acceptable in vitest/jest):
```typescript
it("returns error response for invalid JSON")
it("destroys connection when payload exceeds 64KB")
```

## Test Structure: AAA (Arrange-Act-Assert)

```typescript
it("returns sum of two numbers", () => {
// Arrange
const calc = new Calculator();

// Act
const result = calc.add(2, 3);

// Assert
expect(result).toBe(5);
});
```

**Rules:**
- One logical assertion per test (multiple `expect` calls OK if verifying one exit point)
- No logic in tests (no `if`, `switch`, `for`, `try/catch`)
- No shared mutable state between tests
- Tests must be independent and run in any order

## Exit Point Categories & Patterns

### 1. Return Value Tests (simplest)
```typescript
it("parses duration string to milliseconds", () => {
expect(parseDuration("6h")).toBe(21_600_000);
});
```

### 2. State Change Tests
```typescript
it("marks job as paused after pause()", async () => {
const store = new CronStore(tmpDir);
await store.writeJob(makeJob({ id: "x", enabled: true }));

await store.pauseJob("x");

const job = await store.readJob("x");
expect(job.enabled).toBe(false);
});
```

### 3. Dependency Call Tests (use fakes/stubs)
```typescript
it("sends notification to transport on notify request", async () => {
const sent: string[] = [];
const fakeTransport = { notify: async (_ids: number[], text: string) => { sent.push(text); } };

await handler({ type: "notify", text: "hello" }, fakeTransport);

expect(sent).toEqual(["hello"]);
});
```

## Stub vs Mock vs Fake

| Type | Purpose | Assertion target? |
|------|---------|-------------------|
| **Stub** | Returns canned data | No — just enables the test |
| **Mock** | Records calls for verification | Yes — assert it was called correctly |
| **Fake** | Working implementation (in-memory) | No — used as real substitute |

**Rule:** Prefer fakes > stubs > mocks. Only mock when verifying a dependency call exit point.

## Anti-Patterns to Avoid

1. **Testing implementation** — Don't assert private methods, internal state, or call order unless it's the exit point
2. **Overspecified tests** — Don't verify every parameter; verify what matters
3. **Test-per-method** — Don't mirror 1:1 with methods; test behaviors/scenarios
4. **Shared state** — Don't use `beforeAll` to set up mutable state shared across tests
5. **Magic values** — Use named constants or builder functions for test data
6. **Flaky async** — Don't use `setTimeout` to "wait" for async; use proper awaits/events
7. **Testing the framework** — Don't test that vitest/jest assertions work

## Isolation Strategies

### For I/O (filesystem, network):
```typescript
// Use temp directories
const tmpDir = resolve(tmpdir(), `test-${process.pid}`);
afterEach(() => rmSync(tmpDir, { recursive: true, force: true }));

// Use injectable paths/sockets
const server = new IpcServer(handler, TEST_SOCKET_PATH);
```

### For time:
```typescript
// Use vi.useFakeTimers() or inject a clock
vi.useFakeTimers();
vi.advanceTimersByTime(60_000);
vi.useRealTimers();
```

### For external services:
```typescript
// Inject fakes via constructor or parameter
const fakeNotifier = { notify: vi.fn().mockResolvedValue(undefined) };
const runner = new CronRunner(store, fakeNotifier);
```

## Coverage Checklist

For each unit, ask:
1. What are the **entry points**? (How is it invoked?)
2. What are the **exit points**? (What observable things happen?)
3. For each exit point, what are the **scenarios**?
- Happy path
- Edge cases (empty input, boundary values)
- Error paths (invalid input, dependency failure)
- Concurrency (if applicable)

## Readability Rules

- Test file mirrors source: `src/ipc/server.ts` → `test/ipc-server.test.ts`
- Group by unit: `describe("IpcServer", () => { ... })`
- Helper functions at bottom of file or in `test/helpers/`
- Builder pattern for complex test objects:
```typescript
function makeJob(overrides: Partial<CronJobConfig> = {}): CronJobConfig {
return { id: "test", enabled: true, prompt: "do stuff", ...overrides };
}
```

## When to Stop Testing

- Don't test trivial code (getters, simple delegation)
- Don't test third-party libraries
- Don't test generated/derived code
- Stop at the trust boundary — if a dependency is tested elsewhere, stub it
Loading